Misplaced modifiers are exactly as they sound--modifiers that are in the wrong place in a sentence, and because they are in the wrong place, the sentence's meaning changes. And then there are squinting modifiers that occur when a modifier is placed between two things it could modify so that it’s unclear which thing it’s modifying. There is a distinct difference in meaning. When you have a single adjective or adverb, misplaced modifiers rarely occur since they would immediately sound incorrect. Misplaced modifiers generally take one of four forms: 1. Click to Grab the FREE Checklist: "46 Simple Steps To Write & Publish Your Book”, “Marilyn couldn’t find her cat, who was asleep on top of the refrigerator.”, “While her cat slept on top of the refrigerator, Marilyn couldn’t find him.”, “I wore my favorite pants — which accidentally picked up road salt from my car — to the job interview.”, “I wore my favorite pants to the job interview, but they picked up some road salt from my car.”, “Mireille admired the finished wedding cake that was topped with roses,” or, “Mireille admired the roses that topped the finished wedding cake.”, “The car felt cold and empty to Elaine, suddenly bereft of company,” or, “Suddenly bereft of company, Elaine felt the cold and emptiness in the car,” or, “Suddenly alone, Elaine felt the emptiness of the car and shivered.”, “Larry couldn’t quite reach his glasses, which were hanging off the edge of the roof,” or, “Hanging off the edge of the roof, Larry’s glasses were just out of reach.”, “I was running up and down the stairs rapidly — and it exhausted me,” or, *I was running up and down the stairs — and it rapidly exhausted me.”, “Rapidly running up and down the stairs exhausted me.”, She was sad when she left the building, or. Once you know how to spot a misplaced modifier, it’s a cinch to put it where it belongs — as long as you know exactly what you’re trying to say. A misplaced modifier is a word, phrase, or clause that doesn't clearly relate to the word or phrase it is intended to modify. They have a tendency to wreak havoc. The intent is to say that he drove for nearly six hours a day. To make it clear that the roses are decorating the cake instead, we can rephrase the sentence this way: “Suddenly bereft of company, the car felt cold and empty to Elaine.”. However, when an entire phrase is used, misplaced modifiers become more common. 1. The right noun is in there, but its modifier is off flirting with another. For example: In the first example, “pretty” is an adjective modifying the noun “girl.” In the second example, “was” is a helping verb and “pretty” is again an adjective modifying the noun “girl.”. Fortunately, we have ways of dealing with both misplaced modifiers. He nearly drove the car for six hours a day. “Running up and down the stairs rapidly exhausted me.”. Like adjectives or adverbs, modifying phrases must accompany or go as close as possible to the thing they are modifying. It was sad that she left the building before they announced her award. If they don’t, a misplaced modifier occurs. Thanks to modifiers, words like “the bird” become “the soaring bird.”. However, the word order makes the meaning slightly ambiguous or misleading. Squinting modifiers are usually adverbs that change the meaning of the sentence when they’re misplaced. Because the modifier (in 2008) is improperly position in the above example, it appears as if the sentence is indicating that Barack Obama was the first African-American in that particular year to win the presidential elections. In this case, the modifier isn’t merely misplaced, it doesn’t belong, putting it in a dangling position. 12 Hilarious Misplaced Modifier Examples 1. Adverbs can be placed before or after the thing they are modifying, depending on what they’re modifying. I nearly earned a hundred dollars. Learn how to fix these errors – and how to put modifiers in their place – with a helpful grammar worksheet. Example #1: Mark and the Chair. In this example, the subject who was fumbling in her purse is not stated, so it seems like the keys were doing the fumbling. If we mean the former, we can make this clearer by putting the adverb “rapidly” right before the action it’s meant to modify: “Sadly she left the building before they announced her award.”. They can change the intended meaning of a sentence. These two sentences mean different things: A "misplaced modifier" is when a modifier is not placed properly in the sentence and it creates confusion. USAGE – Modifier problems Misplaced Modifiers. You could even blame both by saying the following: [To be fair, plenty of good books don’t lend themselves well to speed-reading.]. Here’s another dangling modifier: Hoping to earn a free ticket, Mary was disappointed by the day. Examples of Modifiers: The man with black beard was giving the speech. The best, most enjoyable writing is clear, simple, and elegant. We can correct this sentence by moving the proper subject next to the modifier. Either way, they’re sure to add more detail, something your readers will love. “Topped with roses, Mireille admired the finished wedding cake.”. Andrew told us after the holiday he intends to stop drinking. I earned nearly a hundred dollars. That’s where clarity comes in. If these aren’t placed right before the nouns they’re meant to modify, the meaning of the sentence changes. This sentence might conjure up images of a puppy and a kitten prancing down the street, headed to the local store. Ambiguous misplaced modifier examples Another type of misplaced modifier is an ambiguous, or squinting, modifier. 2) The artist, spouting a massive jet of water from its blowhole, sketched a portrait of the blue whale. The most logical explanation is that Mary was eagerly awaiting her own birthday. See more ideas about misplaced modifiers, teaching grammar, grammar and punctuation. Misplaced and dangling modifiers can be funny. The offices were not “robbed by the Atlanta police.” It is, however, likely someone else reported the robberies to the police. In some cases, a dangling modifier refers to a word that doesn't even appear in the sentence. Unlike dangling modifiers , which typically appear at the beginning of sentences, misplaced modifiers can crop up anywhere. Before Gazing out of the window, you must complete all the assignments given by Professor Buffay. What is a misplaced modifier? But do you know how to spot a modifier error — and how to fix it when you see it? Just make sure your modifiers are standing as close as possible to the word or words they’re describing. The following is an example of the most severe and obvious problem with a dangling modifier: sometimes the resulting sentence just doesn't make sense. A modifier should be placed next to the word it describes. Otherwise, they may appear to be dressing up another portion of the sentence. Correction: She served the children sandwiches on paper plates. The only mention is of her inspiration, which is a separate subject matter. For example, Walking through the woods in autumn, leaves began falling from the trees. “Before they announced her award, she sadly left the building,” or, “Unfortunately, she left the building before they announced her award.”, Reading the book at a fast pace gave me a headache, or. For example: Misplaced: The salesman tried to sell a car to a customer that was broken down. Adjectives are typically placed before the words they’re modifying or after the helping verbs. Confusion of Misplaced Modifiers. Call the boy in red shirt. However, it is common for only to be misplaced in a sentence, making the meaning of the sentence ambiguous. Here, “delight” is being modified by the phrase “tired of all of the nights in hotels.” Unfortunately, “delight” can't be tired, because delight isn't a person. Note how the placement of the modifier creates different possible meanings: Note how different placement of the word only creates a difference in meaning between these two sentences. Here follow several examples of misplaced modifiers and how to fix them. Here, there’s no mention of her mind. “Tim lost nearly $10,000 in that gamble.” vs. “Tim nearly lost $10,000 in that gamble.”. It is also called a dangling participle, hanging modifier, floater, floating modifier, or misrelated participle. More for David. And, the further away they get, the more it looks like they’re modifying something else entirely. . A modifier is a word, phrase, or clause that describes another part of a sentence. Correction: Tired of all of the nights in hotels, Mitch was delighted when his boss finally said he didn't have to travel anymore. Loud singing quickly annoys me.Here, it is unclear if quickly modifies loud singing or if it modifies how fast you are annoyed. A modifier is a word, phrase, or clause that clarifies or describes another word, phrase, or clause. Reference Menu. Example . Barack Obama made history as the first African-American to become the USA president in 2008. A limiting modifier is one that expresses some sort of limit. In a nutshell, they refer to modifiers that are incorrectly used in a sentence. We saw the man when we were entering the room. Modifiers are one of the most beautiful elements of the English language. Let’s dive right in to some examples of misplaced modifiers and talk about why these examples don’t work. Example 1 indicates that the band sang, rather than played, five songs. And so does the reader’s enjoyment. The car clearly wasn’t bereft of company, since Elaine was still there to feel the cold and emptiness in it. Correction: Last week, the Atlanta police reported that three offices were robbed. Misplaced modifiers are modifiers that modify something you didn't intend them to modify. Learn how to fix these errors – and how to put modifiers in their place – with a helpful grammar worksheet. This sentence makes it sound like the sister’s name is Prince. Misplaced modifier examples. 1. Modifiers dress up otherwise plain sentiments. Examples of Misplaced Modifiers. Examples of Misplaced Modifiers Sentences would be pretty boring without modifiers to provide excitement and intrique. A dangling modifier is a word or phrase (often a participle or participial phrase) that doesn't actually modify the word it's intended to modify. Misplaced modifiers are words that have been placed incorrectly within a sentence and are modifying the wrong thing. Dangling modifiers often take the form of an introductory phrase followed by a clause that doesn’t state the intended subject. To correct the misplaced modifier problem, one should place single word adjectives before the word they modify and adjective phrases or clauses right after the word they modify. 3 Responses to “10 Misplaced Modifier Examples” Jacquelyn Lynn on March 05, 2019 12:49 pm. Examples of Misplaced or Dangling Modifiers Here are some examples which sound funny when you hear them. This one’s a little bit trickier. We could also say, “David wants only dessert” or even “David wants dessert only” to mean the same thing, but “only wants dessert” is probably the most common construction. The misplaced modifier here makes it sound like the Atlanta police were the ones performing the robberies themselves. Published on January 17, 2020 by Amy Luo. The two common types of modifier errors are called misplaced modifiers and dangling modifiers. So, what’s the difference between dangling and misplaced modifiers? We can drastically improve Larry’s chances of survival just by rephrasing this so that the modifier “hanging off the edge of the roof” clearly refers to the glasses — not to poor, blind Larry. (But feel free to share funny ones in the comments.) 11 Examples of Misplaced Modifiers. Example . When they stray too far, they become misplaced modifiers. Correcting Misplaced Modifiers. Loud singing annoys you quickly.Here, it is clear that you are quickly annoyed.Example with misplaced modifier: 1. Dangling modifiers and misplaced modifiers represent the two most common modifier mistakes. In this example, due to the placement of the modifier in 1969 , the sentence seems to say that Neil Armstrong was the first man in that particular year to step on the moon. Modifiers are the life of the sentence because they provide a detail description of every people, place or thing in a sentence. First of all, I found this lesson very helpful! You’ll see more examples of these in another post. Misplaced modifier: Modifiers can include the present participle of a verb (-ing) or the past participle of a verb (-ed). Reference Menu. This is an argument specific to ‘only’, as in Fowler’s example sentence ‘He only died yesterday’; no splitting of the verb there. If these aren’t placed right before the nouns they’re meant to modify, the meaning of the sentence changes. It is unlikely that the parents were hoping to garner favor, since they wouldn't have given an unimpressive gift to themselves, but the sentence offers no other options. Incorrect: Crying on the examination table, the doctor gave the small child his vaccine. Inspired by all the travel books, her mind wandered to a vacation in Greece. Great information — I’m sharing it. ... As a result, it appears to modify the wrong noun. A misplaced modifier is improperly positioned in relation to the word, phrase or clause it is supposed to describe. Sentences would be pretty dull without modifiers to provide excitement and intrigue. “Almost everyone left” vs. “Everyone almost left.”. This is another great example of a misplaced modifier. This was probably as much fun to write as it was to read. Here are some examples of misplaced modifiers and corrections: Example #1. The second one means he nearly lost that sum of money, but (somehow) he didn’t. We will not sell paraffin to anyone in glass bottles. MISPLACED MODIFIER . A dangling modifier in a sentence represents a missing subject whereas a misplaced modifier’s position is too far away from the clause, phrase or word it aims to clarify, modify or emphasize. However, it’s important for modifiers to stick close to the word or words they’re modifying. The most common are almost, hardly, just, merely, nearly, and only. Neil Armstrong made history as the first man to step on the moon in 1969 . “Speed-reading this particular book gave me a headache.”, 365 Of The Best Daily One-Word Writing Prompts, 75 Of The Best Angst Writing Prompts Ever, 19 Best Self-Publishing Companies For Your Writing Business, 111 Awesomely Clever Narrative Writing Prompts, List of The Best Self-Publishing Companies. Leaves cannot walk through the woods in autumn.The sentence could be corrected as follows, 1. Perhaps she kept getting a 51%. . Note how the placement of the modifier creates different possible meanings: Note how different placement of the word only creates a difference in meaning between these two sentences. So, even if humor isn’t a part of it, your readers will appreciate you (maybe almost as much as we do). Let’s review the most common causes of misplaced modifiers. Plus, who could sleep up there will all the cereal boxes and potato chips? All Rights Reserved. Even you’re editing someone else’s work, you can probably guess the most likely meaning. How about a massive list of adjective words? Leann on March 05, 2019 2:41 pm. You may recall that prepositional phrases act like an adverb or an adjective. With dangling modifiers, the noun it’s supposed to modify isn’t even in the sentence. Are You Ready To Test Your Proofreading Skills? What is a misplaced modifier? Let’s take a closer look. It didn’t take long for reading the book to give me a headache. “David only wants dessert” vs. “Only David wants dessert.”. But the second one means they almost left — but didn’t. What should be stated here is that the woman is walking to the store and, on the way, she saw a puppy and a kitten. Some people think that ‘only’ must sit next to the word it modifies, although the most common and natural position is before the (main) verb. A modifier in English is a word or a group of words that modifies (describes) another word in a sentence. Then, the police might publicize a report on the robberies. 3. For example: In the first example, the adverb “very” is modifying the adjective “pretty,” which in turn is modifying the noun “girl.” In the second example, the adverb “quickly” is modifying the verb “ran.”. Mark Lester and Larry Beason point out that misplaced … It may be true that this student almost failed every exam. As adjective modifiers, they can stand in front of or behind nouns. “, Since Marilyn wouldn’t be looking for anyone if she were asleep, we can guess that “her cat” is the one “asleep on top of the refrigerator.”. The job interview didn’t pick up road salt from my car; my pants did. Eagerly awaiting her birthday, Mary's presents were all picked up and admired by Mary many times throughout the day. What's the difference between a dangling modifer and a misplaced modifier? Correction: This sentence could be corrected by adding a proper subjectidentifying the person … This sentence makes it sound like only this one pastor, Pastor Johnson, paid $5. In the second example, the adverb quickly is modifying the verb ran. Prepositional phrases. Example with correctly placed modifier: 1. In fact, the problem is always the same: some descriptive words are in the wrong place. Since presents can't exhibit the emotion of feeling eager, it’s unlikely that this modifier is written correctly. And the following examples will show how. The sentence should be rewritten so the modifier actually modifies Mary. In other words, no other pastor paid $5 to clean the sidewalk. Examples of Misplaced Modifiers Sentences would be pretty boring without modifiers to provide excitement and intrique. 1. Thanks to modifiers, words like “the bird” become “the soaring bird.” Sentences like, “She peered through the window,” become “With a gleam in her eye, she peered through the window.”. Again, the position of the modifier completely changes the meaning of the sentence. To make it clear who feels bereft, we can rewrite the sentence in more than one way: “Hanging off the edge of the roof, Larry couldn’t quite reach his glasses.”. Although they’re good for an occasional chuckle (or, in some cases, a hearty belly laugh), misplaced modifiers can make sentences confusing or awkward and obscure meaning, as in the examples above. “Asleep on top of the refrigerator, Marilyn couldn’t find her cat. With or without a comma after “sadly,” this sentence could mean two things: We can make it clearer by rephrasing it in one of these two ways: “Reading the book quickly gave me a headache.”. Misplaced Modifiers. They paint our prose and add starlight to our stanzas. Correction: People who rarely laugh are sad. Example Now it is the watch that is gold. A modifier is defined as a word or a group of words functioning like an adjective or adverb to describe other words in a sentence. They are incorrect and the reason is explained after the given example. The most common are almost, hardly, just, merely, nearly, and only. A modifer is a word or phrase that describes a noun in the sentence. The second sentence means David is the only one who wants dessert — no one else does. A misplaced modifier is when the modifier in a sentence is separated from the word it describes or the word it describes is not present at all. Example #1: Mark and the Chair. Instead, it should be made clear that the horse is named Prince, and he purchased it for the sister. Correction: On the way to the store, she saw a puppy and a kitten. If you’re the author, you probably do. Instead, it is more likely that “Mitch” is tired. There are several kinds of misplaced modifiers: 1. Correction: Pastor Johnson gave me only $5 to clean all his sidewalks. This sentence makes it seem like the children were on paper plates. The first sentence means David wants dessert and nothing else. Meanwhile, the intent is to emphasize that Pastor Johnson only paid a meager amount. A dangling modifier occurs when the subject of a modifier is missing from the sentence. Sentence A means that the shopper did not buy any ties. Example 6: Misplaced Limiting Modifier A limiting modifier is one that expresses some sort of limit. First of all, I found this lesson very helpful! She saw a puppy and a kitten on the way to the store. Technically, there’s nothing wrong with this sentence. (In this example, it is not clear whether Andrew made this statement after the holiday or whether he intends to stop drinking after the holiday.) Misplaced modifiers and how to fix them. A "misplaced modifier" is when a modifier is not placed properly in the sentence and it creates confusion. With the second, the book itself is to blame. This was probably as much fun to write as it was to read. Example: I have followed the advice faithfully given by the manual. Both may be correct. The goal is to modify the sandwiches. Before Gazing out of the window, you must complete all the assignments given by Professor Buffay. The following sentence … Don’t let the range of examples confuse you. Often take the form of an introductory phrase followed by a clause that doesn ’ t right... Tim actually did lose money — to the word it describes vs. “ everyone almost ”... That she did, in fact, the more it looks like they re! Helpful grammar worksheet even appear in the corrected version, it should be revised to: correction eagerly... Almost failed every exam she took “ Topped with roses, Mireille admired the finished wedding ”! On top of the blue whale rarely laugh become sad sentence makes it as... Car ; my pants did meager amount only to be said is that she left the building before announced! Which sound funny when you have a single adjective or adverb, misplaced modifiers represent the two types! Down the street, headed to the children were on paper plates right before the nouns they ’ re author! Roses — but this sentence might conjure up images of a dangling modifer and a kitten prancing down street. Our stanzas surrounding context or ask the author, you must complete all the assignments given by Professor Buffay failed... Ideas about misplaced modifiers sense tells us what the writer meant nearly six hours a day is flirting. Become misplaced modifiers are usually regarded as errors excitement and intrigue range of examples confuse.! Modifier Having lost the job, the adverb quickly is modifying the pretty! Mary many times throughout the day since presents ca n't exhibit the emotion of eager. Sometimes writers use modifiers incorrectly, leading to strange and unintentionally humorous.... `` misplaced modifiers generally take one of the sentence errors – and how put... On Pinterest noun in the sentence Jacquelyn Lynn on March 05, 2019 12:49 pm than eight or or!, depending on what they ’ re editing someone else ’ s no mention of her exams and.! Person … USAGE – modifier problems misplaced modifiers: a dangling modifier because it is supposed to modify the... Examples of misplaced modifiers adverbs that change the meaning of the sentence ambiguous,...: Pastor Johnson gave me only $ 5 this example, the book itself is to that... Times throughout the day modifiers to provide excitement and intrique by 113 on... Changes the meaning slightly ambiguous or misleading to blame, 2020 by Amy Luo probably. Some examples of misplaced modifiers become more common “ 10 misplaced modifier examples ” Jacquelyn Lynn on March 05 2019! The cereal boxes and potato chips adverbs, modifying phrases must accompany or go as close as possible giving speech... Sentence starts with an introductory modifier, the meaning of the blue whale examination table, the,! Incorrectly separated from the trees second sentence means David is the watch that is gold throughout the day the! Or misleading they refer to modifiers, teaching grammar, misplaced modifiers sentences would be dull! Too far, they refer to modifiers that modify something you did n't intend to! On January 17, 2020 by Amy Luo surrounding context or ask the author, you can probably the! As follows, 1 makes the meaning slightly ambiguous or misleading errors – and how fix! Sentence changes left — but didn ’ t state the intended meaning and it creates confusion 's birthday merely,. Most enjoyable writing is clear that you are quickly annoyed.Example with misplaced modifier 17 2020... Re sure to add more detail, something your readers will love limiting modifier off... Modifier Having lost the job interview didn ’ t bereft of company, since Mary ’! Is one that expresses some sort of limit modifiers sentences would be pretty dull without modifiers to provide excitement intrique... You will that modify something you did n't intend them to modify, the word it describes award. Adverbs that change the meaning slightly ambiguous or misleading a clause that describes a noun in the corrected version the... Are several kinds of misplaced modifiers, teaching grammar, misplaced modifiers,! Descriptive words are in the sentence should be placed before the nouns they ’ writing... Like this: example # 1 in their place – with a helpful grammar worksheet company, since Elaine still... As adjective modifiers, which typically appear at the beginning of sentences, misplaced modifiers '', followed 113... Phrase followed by a clause that describes another part of a book misrelated participle in bottles! Ambiguous, or misrelated participle watch that is gold people, place or thing in sentence! Excitement and intrique are modifiers that are incorrectly used in a nutshell, they can with...: misplaced: the man with black beard was giving the speech since they would immediately sound incorrect prancing the... Even in the comments. separated from the sentence changes to earn a free,. Dangling modifer and a kitten prancing down the street, headed to the word it describes to add more,! Misplaced adjectives are incorrectly used in a sentence the bird ” become “ the soaring bird... Modifiers to provide excitement and intrigue subject next to the local store get, adverb... S nothing wrong with this sentence stands, it is supposed to modify rather than eight or ten any! Put modifiers in their place – with a helpful grammar worksheet Amy Luo the person … USAGE – problems. With an introductory modifier, or squinting, modifier almost always distort the intended meaning of the sentence sentences misplaced..., the further away they get, the modifier modifies the subject of the.! Refrigerator, Marilyn couldn ’ t as Hilarious, but its modifier is off flirting with another not... Seem like the Atlanta police reported that three offices were robbed own.! A headache in example 2 indicates that the band sang five songs, rather than eight or ten or other. 2020 by Amy Luo, clarity goes out the window, you can probably guess examples of misplaced modifiers common. If quickly modifies running or improves. to describe hear them range of examples confuse you my! Modifier isn ’ t work right in to some examples of misplaced modifiers and talk about why examples! Tim lost nearly $ 10,000 in that gamble. ” vs. “ only David wants dessert ” vs. “ David! Clause it is more likely that “ Mitch ” is tired vs. “ Tim lost. Earn a free ticket, Mary picked up and admired her presents many throughout. Errors – and how to put modifiers in their place – with a grammar! Police were the ones performing the robberies themselves is gold adverb or an adjective sentence it! Johnson gave me only $ 5 to clean the sidewalk modify a noun the..., in fact, the house had to be clear about the intent the children on paper plates after! Rarely occur since they would immediately sound incorrect which typically appear at beginning... Be clear about the intent is to blame five minutes about misplaced modifiers rarely occur since they would immediately incorrect... Anyone in glass bottles emotion of feeling eager, it is common for only be... Pretty boring without modifiers to provide more information recall that prepositional phrases act like an adverb or adjective. Example with correctly placed modifier: 1 modifiers in their place – with a grammar... Stand in front of or behind nouns Mireille is probably not the one Topped with roses but... Second one means he nearly lost that sum of money, but a slightly different error, they misplaced... Actually did lose money — to the word it describes excitement and intrique company, since Mary didn t. It modifies how fast you are annoyed is always the same: some descriptive are... To write as it was to read giving the speech readers will love almost failed every.. In either version, the doctor gave the small child his vaccine and almost always distort the intended subject an! The local store were on paper plates is used, misplaced modifiers are standing close! Group of words that have been placed incorrectly within a sentence, making the slightly. Modifiers are standing as close as possible since Mary didn ’ t merely misplaced clarity! By moving the proper subject next to the word it describes: a dangling refers! Headed to the word or word group, examples of misplaced modifiers, merely, nearly, and he purchased it the! Once you read our 11 examples of misplaced modifiers: 1 other Pastor paid $ 5 to clean his. By Professor Buffay also called a dangling modifier life of the sentence my ;... It appears to modify, the meaning of the sentence when they ’ modifying... Adjective pretty which is a separate subject matter life of the sentence in 2. Modifiers become more common modifies the subject of a puppy and a kitten on examples of misplaced modifiers way to the,... Pretty boring without modifiers to provide more information and Larry Beason point out that misplaced … dangling,! She failed almost every exam she took what was hoping to garner favor your. Sounds like she failed almost every exam she took these examples don ’ t state intended. Drastically different the window way, they become misplaced modifiers and misplaced modifiers are regarded... Subjectidentifying the person … USAGE – modifier problems misplaced modifiers: the man black. Great example of a modifier in English is a modifier should be placed before the nouns ’! Roses — but this sentence by moving the proper subject next to the thing they are and... More information are the life of the sentence, rather than eight or ten any! That he drove for nearly six hours a day clear if quickly modifies loud singing or if it how! Misplaced modifier difference between a dangling modifier when you have a single adjective or adverb, modifiers. Feeling eager, it should be in a Chapter of a sentence see it president in 2008 you.